Value Fund / Contra Fund comparison
ICICI Prudential Value Fund vs HSBC Value Fund
Over the last 3 years, ICICI Prudential Value Fund returned 10.1% a year versus 13.4% for HSBC Value Fund. The category average was 10.7%. In its deepest fall over the same period, ICICI Prudential Value Fund dropped 5.0% versus 7.2% for HSBC Value Fund. Qonfido rates ICICI Prudential Value Fund Select and HSBC Value Fund Select within the Value Fund / Contra Fund peer group.
Ratings and metrics as of
At a glance
Higher 3-year return
HSBC Value Fund
Smaller worst fall
ICICI Prudential Value Fund
Smoother ride (higher Sharpe)
HSBC Value Fund
Head-to-head
Swap either fund or add a third to see how they line up.
ICICI Prudential Value
Value Fund / Contra Fund
1/4
rounds won
HSBC Value
Value Fund / Contra Fund
2/4
rounds won
Round by round
Three questions in one shape. A bigger triangle = stronger all round.
- ICICI Prudential Value
- HSBC Value
Growth
Who grew money faster?
Average yearly return over the last 3 years.
10.1%13.4%✓Dip protection
Who fell less in the worst dip?
Biggest fall from a peak in the period. Smaller hurts less.
-5.0%✓-7.2%Smooth ride
Who gave a smoother ride?
Return earned for every unit of ups and downs. Higher is smoother.
0.490.56✓
Qonfido rating
Quality vs peers in the same category. Premier is the top tier.
Same tier
What matters most to you?
Quick take for “Balanced”
HSBC Value comes out ahead — it grew money faster and gave a smoother ride for the return.
Based on the last 3 years of data. A starting point for research, not advice.
What could your money become?
If each fund repeated its last 3 years. Drag to try.
You’d put in ₹12.00 L. HSBC Value ends about ₹4.56 L ahead — that’s roughly 46 months of your SIP.
Illustration only. Past returns rarely repeat exactly.
Key numbers
| Metric | ICICI Prudential Value Fund | HSBC Value Fund |
|---|---|---|
| Qonfido rating | Select | Select |
| 3Y return (CAGR) | 10.1% | 13.4% |
| Worst fall (max drawdown) | 5.0% | 7.2% |
| Sharpe ratio (3Y) | 0.49 | 0.56 |
| Beta (3Y) | 0.73 | 1.05 |
| Fund size (AUM) | ₹39,008 Cr | ₹11,275 Cr |
| Category average 3Y return | 10.7% | |
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, ICICI Prudential Value Fund or HSBC Value Fund?
Neither fund is better for every investor. Based on data as of 11 Oct 2026. Over the last 3 years, ICICI Prudential Value Fund returned 10.1% a year versus 13.4% for HSBC Value Fund. The category average was 10.7%. In its deepest fall over the same period, ICICI Prudential Value Fund dropped 5.0% versus 7.2% for HSBC Value Fund. Qonfido rates ICICI Prudential Value Fund Select and HSBC Value Fund Select within the Value Fund / Contra Fund peer group. Which fits depends on your goal, time horizon and comfort with falls. This comparison is educational research support, not personalised investment advice. Past performance does not indicate future returns.
Which has given higher returns, ICICI Prudential Value Fund or HSBC Value Fund?
Based on data as of 11 Oct 2026. Over the last 3 years, ICICI Prudential Value Fund returned 10.1% a year versus 13.4% for HSBC Value Fund. The category average was 10.7%. This comparison is educational research support, not personalised investment advice. Past performance does not indicate future returns.
Which is less risky, ICICI Prudential Value Fund or HSBC Value Fund?
Based on data as of 11 Oct 2026. In its deepest fall over the same period, ICICI Prudential Value Fund dropped 5.0% versus 7.2% for HSBC Value Fund. Sharpe ratio, a measure of return per unit of volatility, was 0.49 for ICICI Prudential Value Fund and 0.56 for HSBC Value Fund. Lower falls and a higher Sharpe ratio point to a smoother past ride, not a guarantee.
What is the Qonfido rating of ICICI Prudential Value Fund and HSBC Value Fund?
Qonfido rates ICICI Prudential Value Fund Select and HSBC Value Fund Select within the Value Fund / Contra Fund peer group. Ratings compare funds with their category peers on risk-adjusted consistency and are explained on the Qonfido rating methodology page.
Should I invest in both ICICI Prudential Value Fund and HSBC Value Fund?
Both funds sit in the Value Fund / Contra Fund category, so their portfolios can overlap and holding both may add limited diversification. Review holdings overlap, costs and your overall allocation before combining them. This comparison is educational research support, not personalised investment advice. Past performance does not indicate future returns.
More Value / Contra fund comparisons
Keep researching
Comparisons are educational research support only. They are not personalised investment advice, suitability assessments, or predictions of returns. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Read scheme documents and consider your goals, horizon, and risk tolerance before investing.